KevinMD September 19, 2024
The fourth major concussion recently suffered by Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa – his third in 24 months – brings into sharp focus the balance between patient/player autonomy and treatment decisions. The right to self-determination, even in sports, has become as much a moral as a medical issue. If Tagovailoa is not able to pass concussion protocols for a third time in his NFL career, he could be forced to retire.
While the intention behind banning repeatedly concussed players is to protect their long-term health, it can be seen as an infringement on players’ autonomy. Some athletes may wish to continue their careers despite the risks, yet are often prevented from doing so by medical regulations aimed at preserving their...