Healthcare DIVE July 18, 2025
Rebecca Pifer

Analysts estimate Humana could lose billions of dollars as a result of the decision.

Dive Brief:

  • A Texas federal judge has dismissed Humana’s lawsuit against the federal government seeking to improve its Medicare Advantage star ratings, in a significant loss for the insurer.
  • Humana sued the CMS in October 2024 to reverse its quality scores, arguing that the agency acted arbitrarily and capriciously in downgrading the ratings, which are tied to billions of dollars in reimbursement, for 2025.
  • However, District Judge Reed O’Connor ruled on Friday that Humana failed to exhaust administrative remedies before filing its lawsuit. Humana said it is exploring further legal action.

Dive Insight:

O’Connor’s decision, which sent Humana’s stock falling 3% on Friday morning,...

Today's Sponsors

Venturous
ZeOmega

Today's Sponsor

Venturous

 
Topics: Insurance, Medicare Advantage
CMS Signals MA Payment Slowdown as Provider Frustration With The Plans Continue to Mount
CMS proposes excluding chart reviews from MA risk scoring in 2027 payment rule
CMS proposes nearly flat Medicare Advantage payments for 2027: 6 notes
Sick of Fighting Insurers, Hospitals Offer Their Own Medicare Advantage Plans
How Risk Adjustment Affects Payment for Medicare Advantage Plans

Share Article